{"text_format":"1","workbook":"xlsx","n_sheets":11,"sheets":["Front Page","Disclaimer","Methodology","RAG","Significance Description","Summary","Site_1","Site_2","Site_3","Site_4","Sheet1"],"not_rendered":{"charts":0,"images":2,"macros":1,"external_links":0,"defined_names":11,"comments":2,"pivot_tables":0},"unopened":[],"bounds":{"document_bytes":16777216,"sheet_cells":100000,"rows_first":2000,"rows_last":500,"rows_between":2000,"halvings":0,"cell_chars":16384,"cell_head_chars":4096},"cells_cut":0,"cells_raw":0,"read":"whole","date_system":"1900"}

{"sheet":"Front Page","index":0,"n_rows":30,"n_cols":11,"rows_kept":30,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[7,2,8,10]]}
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"South Derbyshire District Council    "]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"Regulation 19: Appendix D"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,"Strategic Sites Options Assessment"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Prepared by:"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"SLR Consulting Ltd "]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Project Ref: C0428"]

{"sheet":"Disclaimer","index":1,"n_rows":40,"n_cols":7,"rows_kept":40,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[8,4,8,6],[21,2,34,6],[37,1,37,2],[37,6,37,7],[38,1,38,2],[38,6,38,7],[39,1,39,2],[39,6,39,7],[40,1,40,2],[40,6,40,7],[41,1,41,2],[41,6,41,7]]}
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,"Contract  No:","C0428"]
[]
[null,null,null,"Issue",2]
[]
[null,null,null,"Authors        ","L Jones"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,"Project Director                     ","J Mitchell"]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,"Date:","2025-03-07"]
[]
[]
[null,null,"This document has been prepared by SLR Consulting Ltd with reasonable skill, care and diligence, and taking account of the timescales and resources devoted to it by agreement with South Derbyshire District Council (the Client) as part or all of the services it has been appointed by the Client to carry out. It is subject to the terms and conditions of that appointment.\nSLR shall not be liable for the use of or reliance on any information, advice, recommendations and opinions in this document for any purpose by any person other than the Client. Reliance may be granted to a third party only in the event that SLR and the third party have executed a reliance agreement or collateral warranty.\nInformation reported herein may be based on the interpretation of public domain data collected by SLR, and/or information supplied by the Client and/or its other advisors and associates. These data have been accepted in good faith as being accurate and valid.  \nThe copyright and intellectual property in all drawings, reports, specifications, bills of quantities, calculations and other information set out in this report remain vested in SLR unless the terms of appointment state otherwise.  \nThis document may contain information of a specialised and/or highly technical nature and the Client is advised to seek clarification on any elements which may be unclear to it. \nInformation, advice, recommendations and opinions in this document should only be relied upon in the context of the whole document and any documents referenced explicitly herein and should then only be used within the context of the appointment."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,"VERSION CONTROL RECORD"]
[null,"Issue",null,"Description of Status","Date","Reviewer Initials","Authors Initials"]
[null,1,null,"Draft for Reg 19 SA Report","2025-03-06","JM","LJ"]
[null,2,null,"Final for Reg 19 SA Report","2025-03-07","VP","LJ"]

{"sheet":"Methodology","index":2,"n_rows":23,"n_cols":16,"rows_kept":23,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[[20,0,20,15],[21,0,21,15],[22,0,22,15],[13,7,13,11],[15,0,15,15],[16,0,16,15],[17,0,17,15],[18,0,18,15],[19,0,19,15],[13,2,13,5],[2,1,2,6],[3,1,3,6],[4,1,4,6],[9,1,9,6],[11,0,11,1],[11,6,11,15],[11,2,11,5]]}
["The methodology used for the assessment of all sites is outlined below, with an explanation given under each header. The same assessment matrices has been used for the assessment of all sites, hence all follow the same format. "]
[]
["Site Name"]
["Site Address"]
["Town/Locality"]
["Est Housing Yield/Employment Space"]
["Site Area (ha)"]
["Site Description"]
["Greenfield/Brownfield"]
["Assumptions Made"]
[]
["SA Framework",null,"GIS Inputs",null,null,null,"SA Policy Assessment"]
["SA objective","SA sub-objective","GIS data available?","R","A","G","Direct/\nIndirect","Magnitude","Duration","Spatial Extent","Permanence/ Reversibility","Significance","Description of potential effects","Potential for cumulative effects? ","Mitigation","Enhancements"]
["SA objectives will be listed here","SA sub-objectives will be listed here.","This indicates whether the site could be spatially assessed, and if so, what the RAG rating on the site was for each SA objective",null,null,null,"This indicates if assessors were able to consider the assessment question as part of their assessment. ","Details on the nature of any potential effects will be listed here. For further details and definitions of each category, please see the 'Significance Scores' tab. \nFor cases where a neutral effect has been identified, N/A will be present across columns  H-L. ",null,null,null,null,"A significance score will be selected here, which corresponds with the definitions detailed in the 'Significance Scores' tab. ","The potential effect identified in columns H-L will be detailed here, with justification for the significance score. \nAny information considered as a part of the assessments which has informed these potential effects will also be detailed here. ","Yes or No will be inserted here. If yes, see summary box at the bottom of the matrices for further details of the potential cumulative effect. ","Any mitigation required for potential negative or uncertain effects will be detailed here. If the sole method of preventing a potential adverse effect is to not develop a site, \"No mitigation identified.\" will be written here. "]
[]
["Significant Negative and Uncertain Effects"]
["All potential significant negative and uncertain effects outlined in the assessment above, will be accumulated into this box. "]
["Significant Positive Effects"]
["Any potential significant positive effects identified within the assessment will be detailed here. "]
["Potential Cumulative Effects Identified"]
["Details of any potential cumulative effects, including which SA objectives could be affected, will be outlined here. This could include specific cumulative effects with another site, or those which could arise as a result of all development across the district. "]
["Mitigation and enhancements"]
["Details of all  mitigation listed in column O and any potential enhancements arising from assessment will be summarised against the relevant assessment here. All potential significant negative and uncertain effects will have mitigation listed. "]

{"sheet":"RAG","index":3,"n_rows":8,"n_cols":50,"rows_kept":8,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[2,48,2,49],[2,19,2,20],[2,21,2,22],[2,28,2,30],[2,32,2,36],[2,2,2,8],[2,10,2,17],[2,37,2,40],[2,42,2,43],[2,44,2,47],[2,23,2,27]]}
[]
[null,null,"S01","S01","S01","S01","S01","S01","S01","S02","S03","S03","S03","S03","S03","S03","S03","S03","S05","S06","S06","S07","S07","S08","S08","S08","S08","S08","S09","S09","S09","S010","S011","S011","S011","S011","S011","S012","S012","S012","S012","S013","S014","S014","S015","S015","S015","S015","S016","S016"]
[null,null,"S01",null,null,null,null,null,null,"S02","S03",null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"S05","S06",null,"S07",null,"S08",null,null,null,null,"S09",null,null,"S010","S011",null,null,null,null,"S012",null,null,null,"S013","S014",null,"S015",null,null,null,"S016"]
[null,"Option","Proximity to River Mease SAC","SSSI proximity","Within SSSI impact risk zone","Parks and informal open space","Local Wildlife Sites & potential LWS","Proximity to Tree Preservation orders","Proximity to LIGS","Affordable housing","Proximity to GP Practice","Primary and secondary school capacity","Proximity to existing or planned primary school ","Proximity to existing or planned secondary school ","Proximity to existing and planned employment sites via active travel","Proximity to formal recreation e.g., sport centre, play parks","Proximity to informal recreation space i.e., open space","Proximity to retail facilities","IMD deprivation scores","IMD deprivation scores","Provision of retail and town centre uses","Provision of employment space","Proximity to existing and planned employment areas","Proximity to GP Practice","Proximity to existing or planned primary school ","Proximity to existing or planned secondary school ","Proximity to existing and planned employment sites via active travel","Proximity to town/ village centre","Proximity to train station","Proximity to bus stop","Proximity to existing cycle routes ","Proximity to town/ village centre via active travel","Agricultural Land Classifications","Mineral source protection zone (sand and gravel, grit, and coal)","Historic Landfill Sites","Brownfield Land","Contaminated Land","Distance to groundwater protection zones","Distance to River Mease SAC nutrient neutrality zone","Noise pollution ","Night blight map ","Distance to EV charging points ","Flood risk","Proximity to watercourse","Ancient Monuments & Buffer","Conservation Areas","Listed Buildings","Historic parks and gardens","Greenbelt","AMES sensitivity regions"]
[null,"Site_1","G","G","G","G","R","R","R","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","R","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","R","R","G","G","R","A","A","G","R","A","G","G","R","A","R","R","A","G","G","G","G","G","G"]
[null,"Site_2","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","G","A","G","G","A","R","G","G","R","G","G","G","G","R","A","G","A","R","R","R","R","R","R","G","R","G","R","A","G","G","R","G","R","A","A","G","G","G","G","R","G"]
[null,"Site_3","G","G","G","R","G","A","G","G","R","G","G","A","R","R","R","R","G","G","G","G","G","R","G","A","R","R","R","G","G","R","A","G","G","R","A","G","G","R","A","A","A","A","G","G","G","G","G","G"]
[null,"Site_4","G","G","G","R","R","R","A","G","A","G","G","A","R","R","R","A","A","A","G","G","G","A","G","A","R","A","R","G","G","A","A","A","A","R","A","G","G","G","A","R","R","R","G","G","G","G","G","A"]

{"sheet":"Significance Description","index":4,"n_rows":28,"n_cols":10,"rows_kept":28,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[21,7,26,7],[21,8,26,8],[21,9,26,9],[27,7,36,7],[27,8,36,8],[27,9,36,9],[2,1,2,2],[2,7,2,9],[4,7,11,7],[4,8,11,8],[4,9,11,9],[7,1,10,1],[11,1,14,1],[12,7,18,7],[12,8,18,8],[12,9,18,9],[15,1,18,1]]}
[]
[]
[null,"Nature of effects",null,null,null,null,null,"Significance Scores"]
[null,"Criterion","Description",null,null,null,null,"Symbol","Definitions of Significance of Effects Against the SA Objectives","Assumptions on the nature of effects"]
[null,"Significance ","An assessment of the significance of the potential effects identified. This could be a positive effect, negative effect, neutral effect, significant positive effect or significant negative effect. The definitions for these effects are detailed to the right.",null,null,null,null,"++","Significant Positive Effect: the policy option supports the achievement of this objective; it addresses all relevant assessment questions and could result in a potentially significant beneficial effect e.g. improved access by walking and cycling modes to a local or town centre","Permanent\nContinual\nMagnitude: High 80%+ receptor or environmental capacity affected; or Medium 40-80% of receptor or environmental capacity of affected\nThe effect could be to:\n•\tenhance and redefine the location in a positive manner, making a contribution at a national or international scale; \n•\trepair or restore receptors badly damaged or degraded through previous uses; and/or \n•\timprove one or more key elements/features/ characteristics of a receptor with recognised quality such as a specific regional or national designation."]
[null,"Permanent/temporary","An assessment of whether the predicted effects would be permanent (P), or temporary (T). "]
[null,"Reversible/Irreversible","An assessment of whether or not the identified effect can be reversed (R) e.g. the loss of greenfield land to development would be irreversible (I). "]
[null,"Spatial extent","How far the effect is predicted to be spread geographically: "]
[null,null,"Low (L) = A specific area within SDDC"]
[null,null,"Medium (M) = Across the entire SDDC, possibly reaching to neighbouring boroughs"]
[null,null,"High (H) = Beyond the SDDC, with national or international ramifications"]
[null,"Magnitude","An assessment of the proportion of the receptor affected by the identified effect. "]
[null,null,"Low (L) =20-40% of receptor or capacity affected ",null,null,null,null,"+","Minor Positive Effect: the policy option supports the achievement of this objective; it addresses some relevant assessment questions, although it may have only a minor beneficial effect","Reversible\nInfrequent or intermittent\nMagnitude: Low 20-40% of receptor or capacity affected.\nThe size, nature and location of a proposed scheme would: \n•\timprove undesignated yet recognised receptor qualities at the neighbourhood scale; \n•\tfit into or with the existing location and existing receptor qualities; and/or\n•\tenable the restoration of valued characteristic features partially lost through other land uses.  "]
[null,null,"Medium (M) = 40-80% of receptor affected"]
[null,null,"High (H) =80+% of the receptor affected"]
[null,"Duration ","An assessment of the time period the predicted effects are likely to last. This could be:"]
[null,null,"Short (S)= 0-5 years"]
[null,null,"Medium (M) = 5-10 years"]
[null,null,"Long (L)= 10 years or more, up to the end of the Local Plan period "]
[null,"Direct/Indirect","An assessment of whether the predicted effect will be directly (D) as a result of option implementation, or indirectly (I) caused by the policy option. ",null,null,null,null,0,"Neutral Effect: the policy option has no impact or effect and is neutral insofar as the benefits and drawbacks appear equal and neither is considered significant"]
[null,"Likelihood","An assessment of how likely it is that the implementation of the policy option will lead to the precited effect. This could be low (L), moderate (M) or high (H). ",null,null,null,null,"?","Uncertain Effect: Uncertain or insufficient information on which to determine the assessment this stage","N/A"]
[null,"Cumulative effect","An assessment of whether or not there is potential for a cumulative effect to occur on the IIA objective as a result of the policy option working in combination with other circumstances, policies or factors. Y= potential cumulative effect. No potential cumulative effect identified. ",null,null,null,null,"-","Minor Negative Effect: the policy option appears to conflict with the achievement of this objective; it does not address relevant assessment questions and may result in minor adverse effects","Reversible\nInfrequent or intermittent\nMagnitude: Low 20-40% of receptor or capacity affected.\nThe size, nature and location of a proposed scheme would: \n•\tbe out of scale with the location; or \n•\tleave an adverse impact on a receptor of recognised quality such as a specific district or county designation."]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"- -","Significant Negative Effect: the policy option works against the achievement of this objective; it could exacerbate a negative situation and may result in a potentially significant adverse effect e.g. loss of all or part of a designated ecological site of national importance.","Permanent \nIrreversible\nContinual\nMagnitude: High 80%+ receptor or environmental capacity affected; or Medium 40-80% of receptor or environmental capacity of affected\nThe effect could be to:\n•\tpermanently degrade, diminish or destroy the integrity of the receptor; \n•\tcause a very high quality receptor to be permanently changed and its quality diminished; \n•\tcannot be fully mitigated and may cumulatively amount to a severe adverse effect;  \n•\tbe at a considerable variance to the location, degrading the integrity of the receptor; and/or \n•\twill be substantially damaging to a high quality receptor such as a specific regional or national designation."]

{"sheet":"Summary","index":5,"n_rows":8,"n_cols":41,"rows_kept":8,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[]}
[]
[null,"M",12,13,14,15,16,17,18,19,20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27]
[null,"Site Name","S01","S02","S03","S04","S05","S06","S07","S08","S09","S010","S011","S012","S013","S014","S015","S016",null,null,"Site Name","S01","S02","S03","S04","S05","S06","S07","S08","S09","S010","S011","S012","S013","S014","S015","S016",null,null,"Significant positive","+ +"]
[null,"Site_1",{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$C$2)","v":"Minor Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$D$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$E$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$F$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$G$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$H$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$I$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$J$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$K$2)","v":"Minor Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$L$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$M$2)","v":"Significant Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$N$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$O$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$P$2)","v":"Minor Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$Q$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B4&\"!\"&$B$2&$R$2)","v":"Uncertain"},null,null,"Site_1",{"$f":"INDEX($AO$3:$AO$8,MATCH(C4, $AN$3:$AN$8,0))","v":"+"},"+ +",0,0,0,"+ +","+ +",0,"+",0,"--","?",0,"-",0,"?",null,null,"Minor Positive","+"]
[null,"Site_2",{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$C$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$D$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$E$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$F$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$G$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$H$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$I$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$J$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$K$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$L$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$M$2)","v":"Significant Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$N$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$O$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$P$2)","v":"Minor Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$Q$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B5&\"!\"&$B$2&$R$2)","v":"Significant Negative"},null,null,"Site_2","+ +","+ +",0,0,0,"+ +","+ +",0,"?",0,"--","?",0,"-",0,{"$f":"INDEX($AO$3:$AO$8,MATCH(R5, $AN$3:$AN$8,0))","v":"--"},null,null,"Neutral",0]
[null,"Site_3",{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$C$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$D$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$E$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$F$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$G$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$H$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$I$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$J$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$K$2)","v":"Minor Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$L$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$M$2)","v":"Significant Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$N$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$O$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$P$2)","v":"Minor Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$Q$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B6&\"!\"&$B$2&$R$2)","v":"Uncertain"},null,null,"Site_3","+ +","+ +",0,0,0,"+ +","+ +",0,"+",0,"--","?",0,"-","?","?",null,null,"Uncertain","?"]
[null,"Site_4",{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$C$2)","v":"Minor Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$D$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$E$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$F$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$G$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$H$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$I$2)","v":"Significant Positive"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$J$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$K$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$L$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$M$2)","v":"Significant Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$N$2)","v":"Uncertain"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$O$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$P$2)","v":"Minor Negative"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$Q$2)","v":"Neutral"},{"$f":"INDIRECT($B7&\"!\"&$B$2&$R$2)","v":"Uncertain"},null,null,"Site_4","+","+ +",0,0,0,"+ +","+ +",0,0,0,"--","?",0,"-",0,"?",null,null,"Minor Negative","-"]
[null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,null,"Significant Negative","--"]

{"sheet":"Site_1","index":6,"n_rows":27,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":27,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[9,0,9,2],[9,7,9,17],[9,3,9,6]]}
["Site Name",null,"Site_1"]
["Site Address",null,"Infinity Garden Village"]
["Town/Locality",null,"Barrow Upon Trent; Stenson Fields; Twyford and Stenson and Swarkestone"]
["Est Housing Yield/Employment Space",null,"2000 dwellings, 70ha employment land"]
["Site Area (ha)",null,205]
["Site Description",null,"The development of this site will also provide:\n- Provision of Gypsy and Traveller pitches\n- Primary vehicle accesses via a new junction on the A50 and junctions via Infinity Park Way\n- A new local centre (including retail facilities)\n- A two form entry primary school\n- A secondary school (including community sport facilities)\n- Recreation facilities"]
["Greenfield/Brownfield",null,"Greenfield"]
["Assumptions Made",null,"This allocation will work alongside the policies set out in the South Derbyshire Local Plan Part 1."]
[]
["SA Framework",null,null,"GIS Inputs",null,null,null,"SA Policy Assessment"]
["SA objective","SA","SA sub-objective","GIS Data Available?","R","A","G","Direct/\nIndirect","Magnitude","Duration","Spatial Extent","Permanence/ Reversibility","Significance","Description of potential effects","Potential for cumulative effects? ","Policy Mitigation","Mitigation Recommendations","Enhancement Recommendation","SDDC Comments",null,null,"Link "]
["S01 Biodiversity\nTo safeguard and enhance biodiversity (including BAP habitats and species) and geodiversity through biodiversity net gain and improve connectivity between, and access to, green spaces and functional habitats.","S01","· Will it conserve and enhance natural or semi natural habitats including internationally, nationally and locally designated wildlife sites, or create new wildlife habitats, and contribute to the creation of a network of habitats and green infrastructure in the District?\n· Will it protect BAP or protected species and contribute to the delivery of new, or safeguard existing BAP priority species and habitats?\n· Will it protect sites of geological importance?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":4},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permenant/Reversible","Minor Positive","The site contains a local wildlife site, a LIG, and contains a number of TPOs. Development may subsequently negatively impact on biodiversity. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy BNE3 Biodiversity, which requires development to avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG. Therefore, an overall minor positive effect is predicted.","Yes","Policy BNE3 Biodiversity requires developments to  avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG, in line with national policy requirements.",null,"The site should be required to implement blue/green infrastructure where possible, particularly where the site can be connected to the Derby City Green Wedge. The site should also maintain as much existing vegetation as possible. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S02 Housing\nTo ensure everyone has access to sustainable housing, which is affordable, and meets the needs of all residents including the elderly and other vulnerable groups and will support the vitality of existing communities and settlements. ","S02","· Will it reduce the number of households waiting for accommodation or accepted as homeless?\n· Will it increase the number and mix of housing? \n· Will it improve the suitability of new homes for older and disabled people?\n· Will it provide affordable housing for those unable to access market housing?\n· Will it meet the needs of the travelling community and show people?\n· Will it secure infrastructure or community facilities?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":1},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site proposes to provide up to 2000 dwellings. It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy H20 Affordable Housing, which requires developments within 10 or more dwellings to provide 40% of the gross number of dwellings in the form of  'affordable housing', and alongside Policy H19 Housing Balance and Custom/Self-build, which requires developments to provide a mixed size and tenure of dwellings. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S03 Accessibility and Health\nTo improve local accessibility to healthcare, education, employment, retail facilities and recreational resources (including open spaces and sports facilities) and enhance wellbeing, promoting healthy and sustainable lifestyles.","S03","· Will it promote healthy lifestyles?\n· Will it deliver new, or contribute to the expansion or improvement of existing open spaces, green infrastructure, schools or healthcare facilities within reasonable walking distance?\n· Will it deliver growth within reasonable walking distance to a planned or existing major employment area (5ha +) or town centre?\n· Will it improve opportunities for active travel including walking and cycling?\n· Will it deliver services or facilities on-site or elsewhere within the District? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":7},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity, a GP surgery. The site has poor access to: a secondary school and an existing employment site. The site does have good access to a safeguarded site for a secondary school development however. Mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. For example, the site plan references the provision for a new primary and secondary school, employment floor space and recreational facilities, as well as support for the refurbishment of the existing Sinfin Health Centre, which will serve the site. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,"The site should be required to provide infrastructure/community facilities to support growth, such as primary/secondary schools and employment land. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S04 Quality of Life\nTo create safe and attractive places which contribute towards quality of life and community cohesion.","S04","· Will it contribute towards reducing crime or fear of crime?\n· Will it provide attractive places which provide opportunities for communities to mix and meet?","No",null,null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, which requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction. The development of this site in isolation is unlikely to contribute towards designing out crime or enhancing community cohesion. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S05 Inequalities\nEnsure all residents have equitable access to employment, education, community services and facilities irrespective of race, religion, sex, age, sexual orientation, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership or pregnancy/maternity.","S05","· Ensure the option / policy does not have an adverse/ discriminatory impact on protected characteristics/ equality groups?\n· Will it narrow the inequality gap between the richest and poorest in the District?\n· Will it reduce inequalities associated with deprivation across the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","This site is within a low IMD deprivation area. However, development of this site alone will not necessarily reduce the gap between the richest and poorest in the District.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S06 Economy\nTo deliver growth in key employment sectors and support the creation of new and retention of existing businesses in urban and rural areas.","S06","· Will it encourage the creation of new businesses and existing businesses to grow?\n· Will it encourage economic diversification?\n· Will it help support and encourage the growth of the local economy (including in rural areas)?\n· Will it support the enhancement of the District’s tourism and cultural offer?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":2},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will support economic growth by providing 70ha of new employment floorspace. Additionally, although the site is more than 800m away from the nearest town centre, development of the site could also indirectly support existing businesses within Findern local centre and Derby City as residents travel in. Therefore, a potential minor positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,"The site should be required to provide retail facilities to support growth.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S07 Employment\nTo create greater employment opportunities and higher value jobs across the whole District","S07","· Will it help to improve skills levels and access to training within the District?\n· Will it reduce unemployment rates overall and reduce disparities which exist across different parts of the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":2},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will support the provision of employment, by creating permanent and temporary jobs during construction and operation. For example, it is estimated that 530 jobs could be supported over the 20-year construction phase. The site is also located around 3km from a large employment site (the Toyota manufacturing site), and will subsequently be located around 2km from the East Midlands Intermodal Park once built. As a result, there will be a large number of employment opportunities both on- and off-site for residents. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S08 Infrastructure\nTo deliver improved infrastructure to support growth and economic competitiveness of urban and rural businesses and communities.","S08","· Will it minimise the impact of traffic congestion on the strategic and local road network through the delivery of new or enhanced transport infrastructure?\n· Will it provide opportunities to access key services, including doctor’s surgeries, education facilities, employment and town, local or village centres by means other than car?\n· Will it make the best use of other infrastructure which serves new development?","No",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity, a GP surgery. The site has poor access to: a secondary school and an existing employment site. The site does have good access to a safeguarded site for a secondary school development however. Mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. For example, the site plan references the provision for a new primary and secondary school, employment floor space and recreational facilities, as well as support for the refurbishment of the existing Sinfin Health Centre, which will serve the site. New access points to the site will also be developed in order to ease road pressure. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S09 Sustainable Travel\nTo promote sustainable travel habits including walking, cycling and public transport (bus and rail) usage.  ","S09","· Will it reduce journey lengths and times? \n· Will it maximise opportunities for walking and cycling?\n· Will it maximise opportunities to access public transport provision?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":2},"Direct","Medium",null,"Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Positive","The site currently lies within an acceptable distance to an existing bus stop, and to existing cycle routes. The site is more than 800m to a train station however. Policy INF1 highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision and improvement of transport infrastructure. This should improve travel within South Derbyshire, as well as into Derby City. Therefore, a potential minor positive effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. ",null,"The site should be required to provide improved transport facilities (e.g.: new bus stops), as well as connect to existing pedestrian/cycle routes where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S010 Town and Village Centres\nTo ensure that town and village centres are vibrant and viable.","S010","· Will it improve existing shopping facilities within town and village centres? \n· Will it help safeguard existing town and village centres?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located within or adjacent to a town or village centre (it is located on the edge of Derby City, and around 1.5km from the village of Findern). The development of a new local centre within the site would provide local facilities for new residents, enabling some self containment. These facilities would not be designed to provide facilities for the wider area and would not therefore detract from existing town and village centres. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,"Development proposals could be accompanied by an assessment of the impact of the development on the local economy. ",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S011 Resources\nTo minimise waste and ensure the sustainable use and protection of natural resources including greenfield land, soil and minerals resources.  ","S011","· Will it enhance opportunities for increased levels of recycling in the District?\n· Will it improve or remediate contaminated land or reuse previously developed land which has not been restored?\n· Will it protect Best and Most Versatile (BMV) Agricultural Land?\n· Will it avoid the sterilisation of minerals resources?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":1},"Direct","High","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Negative","This site is located on grade 3 agricultural land; development will subsequently lead to the irreversible loss of greenfield land, and soils considered as the 'best and most versatile'. The site also lies partially within a sand and gravel mineral safeguarding zone and a contamination zone; development may subsequently lead to the sterilisation of mineral resources. The development of this site in isolation will likely have no influence on the levels of recycling across South Derbyshire. However, It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, which requires developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection. Therefore, as the loss of greenfield land/Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated, a potential significant negative effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence will require developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection.","Loss of greenfield land and Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S012 Pollution\nTo minimise water, air, light and noise pollution and ensure that future growth does not lead to the further deterioration of environmental conditions.","S012","· Will it contribute to improvements in water quality in the District?\n· Will it avoid increasing noise levels locally or introducing incompatible uses into an already noisy location?\n· Will it avoid deterioration in air quality within the District?\n· Will it avoid exacerbating light pollution by keeping external lighting to the minimum required for safety and security?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site currently experiences high noise pollution and some light pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase both noise and light pollution. The A50 is located adjacent to the site so the site is currently exposed to some air pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase air pollution in South Derbyshire, as well as in Derby City as residents may commute into the city for work. The site does not lie within the River Mease nutrient neutrality zone or any groundwater protection zones. The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures, although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes",null,"The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S013 Contributions to Climate Change \nTo reduce the District’s contribution towards the emission of climate change gases.","S013","· Will it provide opportunities to access local services and facilities by public transport walking or cycling?\n· Will it support the delivery of renewable energy capacity (including small scale or community energy projects)?\n· Will it support the shift toward usage of electric and ultralow emissions vehicles? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located near to an existing EV charger, which may discourage residents use of EV vehicles. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport which will require the development to make provision for EV chargers. Finally, the sites location (near to Derby City) may assist in the development of heat networks incorporating new homes, providing low carbon heating for future residents. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport will require  developments to make provision for EV chargers.",null,"The site should be built to low-carbon standards with high levels of energy efficiency and individual energy generation technologies (e.g.: heat source pumps, solar PV) being be promoted where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S014 Adaptation to Climate Change \nTo manage the effects of climate change including flood risk, reduced water availability and overheating.","S014","· Will it minimise flood risk?\n· Will it include provision of sustainable urban drainage which mimic natural drainage patterns?\n· Will it contribute towards sustainable water use?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Negative","The site lies within Flood Zone 3 and within 1000m of a watercourse, which may place development on the site at risk of flooding, which may place development on the site at risk of flooding. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy SD2 Flood Risk which will require the site to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. Although this won't eradicate flood risk, it will reduce the likelihood of a flood risk event taking place. Therefore, as the site is still at risk of flood events following policy mitigation, a potential minor negative effect is identified.","No","Policy SD2 Flood Risk will require developments to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. ",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S015 Townscape and Historic Environment\nTo conserve and enhance the townscape, historic environment, heritage assets (including known and unknown archaeological sites) and their settings. ","S015","· Will it protect and enhance the condition and setting of historic, cultural, architectural and archaeological features in South Derbyshire?\n· Does it improve the quality of the built environment, and respect and protect existing townscape character?\n· Will it improve access to, and understanding of, the District’s historic and cultural assets for enjoyment and educational purposes?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not within close proximity to any designated heritage assets. Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will also refuse the majority of proposals that lead to substantial harm of a heritage asset, unless it can be demonstrated that the benefit of the development outweighs the harm of damaging the asset. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified. ","No","Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will refuse proposals that would lead to substantial harm, unless if can be demonstrated that benefit outweights the harm.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]
["S016 Landscape\nTo conserve and enhance the District’s landscape character.","S016","· Does it respect and protect existing landscape character?\n· Will it protect sensitive landscapes including those within the World Heritage Site or its buffer or Special Landscape Areas?\n· Will it safeguard landscape features such as hedgerows?\n· Will it avoid intrusion into the greenbelt?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site does not lie within the greenbelt or any areas of multiple environmental sensitivity. However, the development of this site could lead to the 'trapping in' of current green wedges within Derby City, cutting these greenfield land areas off from the surrounding open land. This could alter the current landscape, both within South Derbyshire and Derby City. The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City where possible, in order to minimise impacts of 'trapping', although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation.  Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features.","The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City, in order to maintain a similar landscape pattern. ",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":5}]

{"sheet":"Site_2","index":7,"n_rows":27,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":27,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[9,0,9,2],[9,3,9,6],[9,7,9,17]]}
["Site Name",null,"Site_2"]
["Site Address",null,"Thulston Fields"]
["Town/Locality",null,"Elvaston"]
["Est Housing Yield/Employment Space",null,"1750 dwellings/ up to 10ha employment space"]
["Site Area (ha)",null,108]
["Site Description",null,"The site suggests the provision of:\n- A new local centre\n- A new primary school (including playing fields)\n- Open space\n- New recreation facilities (including sports pitches, play space, community orchard)\n"]
["Greenfield/Brownfield",null,"Greenfield"]
["Assumptions Made",null,"This allocation will work alongside the policies set out in the South Derbyshire Local Plan Part 1."]
[]
["SA Framework",null,null,"GIS Inputs",null,null,null,"SA Policy Assessment"]
["SA objective","SA","SA sub-objective","GIS Data Available?","R","A","G","Direct/\nIndirect","Magnitude","Duration","Spatial Extent","Permanence/ Reversibility","Significance","Description of potential effects","Potential for cumulative effects? ","Policy Mitigation","Mitigation Recommendations","Enhancement Recommendation","SDDC Comments",null,null,"Link "]
["S01 Biodiversity\nTo safeguard and enhance biodiversity (including BAP habitats and species) and geodiversity through biodiversity net gain and improve connectivity between, and access to, green spaces and functional habitats.","S01","· Will it conserve and enhance natural or semi natural habitats including internationally, nationally and locally designated wildlife sites, or create new wildlife habitats, and contribute to the creation of a network of habitats and green infrastructure in the District?\n· Will it protect BAP or protected species and contribute to the delivery of new, or safeguard existing BAP priority species and habitats?\n· Will it protect sites of geological importance?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":7},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permenant/Reversible","Significant Positive","There are no internationally designated/BAP species or habitats located on or near to this site, nor are there any locally designated wildlife sites nearby. Therefore, development of this site is not expected to alter current biodiversity or geodiversity. It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE3 Biodiversity, which requires development to avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,"The site should be required to implement blue/green infrastructure where possible, particularly where the site can be connected to the Derby City Green Wedge. The site should also maintain as much existing vegetation as possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S02 Housing\nTo ensure everyone has access to sustainable housing, which is affordable, and meets the needs of all residents including the elderly and other vulnerable groups and will support the vitality of existing communities and settlements. ","S02","· Will it reduce the number of households waiting for accommodation or accepted as homeless?\n· Will it increase the number and mix of housing? \n· Will it improve the suitability of new homes for older and disabled people?\n· Will it provide affordable housing for those unable to access market housing?\n· Will it meet the needs of the travelling community and show people?\n· Will it secure infrastructure or community facilities?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":1},"Direct","Medium","Long(20+yrs)","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site proposes to provide up to 1750 dwellings. It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy H20 Affordable Housing, which requires developments within 10 or more dwellings to provide 40% of the gross number of dwellings in the form of  'affordable housing', and alongside Policy H19 Housing Balance and Custom/Self-build, which requires developments to provide a mixed size and tenure of dwellings. The site plan also highlights that the site will aim to provide infrastructure/community facilities, including a primary school. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S03 Accessibility and Health\nTo improve local accessibility to healthcare, education, employment, retail facilities and recreational resources (including open spaces and sports facilities) and enhance wellbeing, promoting healthy and sustainable lifestyles.","S03","· Will it promote healthy lifestyles?\n· Will it deliver new, or contribute to the expansion or improvement of existing open spaces, green infrastructure, schools or healthcare facilities within reasonable walking distance?\n· Will it deliver growth within reasonable walking distance to a planned or existing major employment area (5ha +) or town centre?\n· Will it improve opportunities for active travel including walking and cycling?\n· Will it deliver services or facilities on-site or elsewhere within the District? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity.  However, the site has poor access to: a secondary school which is 3km walking distance (with capacity), a GP surgery (over 400m walking distance), and an existing employment site (over 800m walking distance). Mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,"The site should be required to provide infrastructure/community facilities to support growth, such as primary/secondary schools and employment land. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S04 Quality of Life\nTo create safe and attractive places which contribute towards quality of life and community cohesion.","S04","· Will it contribute towards reducing crime or fear of crime?\n· Will it provide attractive places which provide opportunities for communities to mix and meet?","No",null,null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, which requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction. The development of this site in isolation is unlikely to contribute towards designing out crime or enhancing community cohesion. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S05 Inequalities\nEnsure all residents have equitable access to employment, education, community services and facilities irrespective of race, religion, sex, age, sexual orientation, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership or pregnancy/maternity.","S05","· Ensure the option / policy does not have an adverse/ discriminatory impact on protected characteristics/ equality groups?\n· Will it narrow the inequality gap between the richest and poorest in the District?\n· Will it reduce inequalities associated with deprivation across the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","This site is within a low IMD deprivation area. However, development of this site alone will not necessarily reduce the gap between the richest and poorest in the District.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S06 Economy\nTo deliver growth in key employment sectors and support the creation of new and retention of existing businesses in urban and rural areas.","S06","· Will it encourage the creation of new businesses and existing businesses to grow?\n· Will it encourage economic diversification?\n· Will it help support and encourage the growth of the local economy (including in rural areas)?\n· Will it support the enhancement of the District’s tourism and cultural offer?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space. Development here could also indirectly support existing businesses within Aston-on-Trent local centre and Derby City. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S07 Employment\nTo create greater employment opportunities and higher value jobs across the whole District","S07","· Will it help to improve skills levels and access to training within the District?\n· Will it reduce unemployment rates overall and reduce disparities which exist across different parts of the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":1},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","No",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S08 Infrastructure\nTo deliver improved infrastructure to support growth and economic competitiveness of urban and rural businesses and communities.","S08","· Will it minimise the impact of traffic congestion on the strategic and local road network through the delivery of new or enhanced transport infrastructure?\n· Will it provide opportunities to access key services, including doctor’s surgeries, education facilities, employment and town, local or village centres by means other than car?\n· Will it make the best use of other infrastructure which serves new development?","No",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity.  However, the site has poor access to: a secondary school which is 3km walking distance (with capacity), a GP surgery (over 400m walking distance), and an existing employment site (over 800m walking distance). Mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision of community facilities. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S09 Sustainable Travel\nTo promote sustainable travel habits including walking, cycling and public transport (bus and rail) usage.  ","S09","· Will it reduce journey lengths and times? \n· Will it maximise opportunities for walking and cycling?\n· Will it maximise opportunities to access public transport provision?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":0},"N/A","N/A",null,"N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site is more than 800m from a train station, more than 400m from a bus stop, and does not connect to existing cycle routes. There are also issues surrounding access to the site, which is noted as creating issues on the wider road network, despite proposed mitigation. Mitigation is provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision and improvement of transport infrastructure. Due to the issues identified in relation to the road network however, it is it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. ",null,"The site should be required to provide improved transport facilities (e.g.: new bus stops), as well as connect to existing pedestrian/cycle routes where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S010 Town and Village Centres\nTo ensure that town and village centres are vibrant and viable.","S010","· Will it improve existing shopping facilities within town and village centres? \n· Will it help safeguard existing town and village centres?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located within or adjacent to a town or village centre (it is located on the edge of Derby City, and around 1.5km from the village of Aston on Trent). The development of a new local centre within the site would provide local facilities for new residents, enabling some self containment. These facilities would not be designed to provide facilities for the wider area and would not therefore detract from existing town and village centres. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,"Development proposals could be accompanied by an assessment of the impact of the development on the local economy. ",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S011 Resources\nTo minimise waste and ensure the sustainable use and protection of natural resources including greenfield land, soil and minerals resources.  ","S011","· Will it enhance opportunities for increased levels of recycling in the District?\n· Will it improve or remediate contaminated land or reuse previously developed land which has not been restored?\n· Will it protect Best and Most Versatile (BMV) Agricultural Land?\n· Will it avoid the sterilisation of minerals resources?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Negative","The site is located within  a sand and gravel mineral safeguarding zone. This site is also located on grade 2 and 3 agricultural land; development will subsequently lead to the irreversible loss of greenfield land, and soils considered as the 'best and most versatile'. The development of this site in isolation will likely have no influence on the levels of recycling across South Derbyshire. However, Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, will requires developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection. Therefore, as the loss of greenfield land/Grade 2 and 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated, a potential significant negative effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence will require developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection.","Loss of greenfield land and Grade 2 and 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S012 Pollution\nTo minimise water, air, light and noise pollution and ensure that future growth does not lead to the further deterioration of environmental conditions.","S012","· Will it contribute to improvements in water quality in the District?\n· Will it avoid increasing noise levels locally or introducing incompatible uses into an already noisy location?\n· Will it avoid deterioration in air quality within the District?\n· Will it avoid exacerbating light pollution by keeping external lighting to the minimum required for safety and security?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":3},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site currently experiences high noise pollution and high light pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase both noise and light pollution further. The A50 and A6 are located adjacent to the site so the site is currently exposed to some air pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase air pollution in South Derbyshire, as well as in Derby City as residents may commute into the city for work. The site does not lie within the River Mease nutrient neutrality zone or any groundwater protection zones. The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures, although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes",null,"The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S013 Contributions to Climate Change \nTo reduce the District’s contribution towards the emission of climate change gases.","S013","· Will it provide opportunities to access local services and facilities by public transport walking or cycling?\n· Will it support the delivery of renewable energy capacity (including small scale or community energy projects)?\n· Will it support the shift toward usage of electric and ultralow emissions vehicles? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is more than 600m of a public EV charger. However, Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport will require the development to make provision for EV chargers. Additionally, the sites location (near to Derby City) may assist in the development of heat networks incorporating new homes, providing low carbon heating for future residents. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport will require  developments to make provision for EV chargers.",null,"The site should be built to low-carbon standards with high levels of energy efficiency and individual energy generation technologies (e.g.: heat source pumps, solar PV) being be promoted where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S014 Adaptation to Climate Change \nTo manage the effects of climate change including flood risk, reduced water availability and overheating.","S014","· Will it minimise flood risk?\n· Will it include provision of sustainable urban drainage which mimic natural drainage patterns?\n· Will it contribute towards sustainable water use?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Negative","Although the majority of the site lies within Flood Zone 1, an area of the site lies within Flood Zone 2 and within 1000m of a watercourse, which may place development on the site at risk of flooding. However, Policy SD2 Flood Risk will require the site to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. Although this won't eradicate flood risk, it will reduce the likelihood of a flood risk event taking place. Therefore, as the site is still at risk of flood events following policy mitigation, a potential minor negative effect is identified.","No","Policy SD2 Flood Risk will require developments to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. ",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S015 Townscape and Historic Environment\nTo conserve and enhance the townscape, historic environment, heritage assets (including known and unknown archaeological sites) and their settings. ","S015","· Will it protect and enhance the condition and setting of historic, cultural, architectural and archaeological features in South Derbyshire?\n· Does it improve the quality of the built environment, and respect and protect existing townscape character?\n· Will it improve access to, and understanding of, the District’s historic and cultural assets for enjoyment and educational purposes?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not within close proximity to any designated heritage assets. Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will also refuse the majority of proposals that lead to substantial harm of a heritage asset, unless it can be demonstrated that the benefit of the development outweighs the harm of damaging the asset. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified. ","No","Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will refuse proposals that would lead to substantial harm, unless if can be demonstrated that benefit outweighs the harm.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]
["S016 Landscape\nTo conserve and enhance the District’s landscape character.","S016","· Does it respect and protect existing landscape character?\n· Will it protect sensitive landscapes including those within the World Heritage Site or its buffer or Special Landscape Areas?\n· Will it safeguard landscape features such as hedgerows?\n· Will it avoid intrusion into the greenbelt?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":1},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Negative","Although the does not lie within any areas of multiple environmental sensitivity, it does lie within the Greenbelt and a national character area. Development on Greenbelt land would be permanent. Additionally, the development of this site could lead to the 'trapping in' of current green wedges within Derby City, cutting these greenfield land areas off from the surrounding open land. This could alter the current landscape, both within South Derbyshire and Derby City. Mitigation will be provided by Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness, which will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features. The site should also link to existing green wedges within Derby City where possible, in order to minimise impacts of 'trapping', although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, as development on Greenbelt land cannot be mitigated, a potential significant negative effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features.","Loss of Greenbelt land cannot be mitigated.","The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City, in order to maintain a similar landscape pattern. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":6}]

{"sheet":"Site_3","index":8,"n_rows":27,"n_cols":21,"rows_kept":27,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[9,0,9,2],[9,3,9,6],[9,7,9,17]]}
["Site Name",null,"Site_3"]
["Site Address",null,"Land South of Mickleover"]
["Town/Locality",null,"Burnaston"]
["Est Housing Yield/Employment Space",null,"2500 homes"]
["Site Area (ha)",null,200]
["Site Description",null,"The site suggests the provision of:\n- Provision of Gypsy and Traveller pitches\n- A new local centre (including retail facilities)\n- A primary school\n- A secondary school\n- A sports hub\n- Financial contributions towards a secondary school and healthcare\n"]
["Greenfield/Brownfield",null,"Greenfield"]
["Assumptions Made",null,"This allocation will work alongside the policies set out in the South Derbyshire Local Plan Part 1."]
[]
["SA Framework",null,null,"GIS Inputs",null,null,null,"SA Policy Assessment"]
["SA objective","SA","SA sub-objective","GIS Data Available?","R","A","G","Direct/\nIndirect","Magnitude","Duration","Spatial Extent","Permanence/ Reversibility","Significance","Description of potential effects","Potential for cumulative effects? ","Policy Mitigation","Mitigation Recommendations","Enhancement Recommendation",null,null,"Link "]
["S01 Biodiversity\nTo safeguard and enhance biodiversity (including BAP habitats and species) and geodiversity through biodiversity net gain and improve connectivity between, and access to, green spaces and functional habitats.","S01","· Will it conserve and enhance natural or semi natural habitats including internationally, nationally and locally designated wildlife sites, or create new wildlife habitats, and contribute to the creation of a network of habitats and green infrastructure in the District?\n· Will it protect BAP or protected species and contribute to the delivery of new, or safeguard existing BAP priority species and habitats?\n· Will it protect sites of geological importance?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U12&\":$AX$\"&$U12),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U12&\":$AX$\"&$U12),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U12&\":$AX$\"&$U12),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":5},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permenant/Reversible","Significant Positive","There are no internationally designated/BAP species or habitats located on or near to this site, nor are there any locally designated wildlife sites nearby. The site is within 10m of a number of TPOs. However as this allocation works alongside Policy BNE3 Biodiversity, which requires development to avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG, it is very unlikely that these will be damaged or removed during development. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,"The site should be required to implement blue/green infrastructure where possible, particularly where the site can be connected to the Derby City Green Wedge. The site should also maintain as much existing vegetation as possible.",null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S02 Housing\nTo ensure everyone has access to sustainable housing, which is affordable, and meets the needs of all residents including the elderly and other vulnerable groups and will support the vitality of existing communities and settlements. ","S02","· Will it reduce the number of households waiting for accommodation or accepted as homeless?\n· Will it increase the number and mix of housing? \n· Will it improve the suitability of new homes for older and disabled people?\n· Will it provide affordable housing for those unable to access market housing?\n· Will it meet the needs of the travelling community and show people?\n· Will it secure infrastructure or community facilities?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U13&\":$AX$\"&$U13),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U13&\":$AX$\"&$U13),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U13&\":$AX$\"&$U13),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":1},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site proposes to provide up to 2500 dwellings. It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy H20 Affordable Housing, which requires developments within 10 or more dwellings to provide 40% of the gross number of dwellings in the form of  'affordable housing', and alongside Policy H19 Housing Balance and Custom/Self-build, which requires developments to provide a mixed size and tenure of dwellings. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S03 Accessibility and Health\nTo improve local accessibility to healthcare, education, employment, retail facilities and recreational resources (including open spaces and sports facilities) and enhance wellbeing, promoting healthy and sustainable lifestyles.","S03","· Will it promote healthy lifestyles?\n· Will it deliver new, or contribute to the expansion or improvement of existing open spaces, green infrastructure, schools or healthcare facilities within reasonable walking distance?\n· Will it deliver growth within reasonable walking distance to a planned or existing major employment area (5ha +) or town centre?\n· Will it improve opportunities for active travel including walking and cycling?\n· Will it deliver services or facilities on-site or elsewhere within the District? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U14&\":$AX$\"&$U14),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":5},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U14&\":$AX$\"&$U14),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U14&\":$AX$\"&$U14),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity.  However, the site has poor walking access to: a secondary school which is 3km walking distance (with capacity), a GP surgery, an existing employment site, and formal and informal recreation which are all over 800m walking distance. Policy INF1 highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. For example, the site plan references the provision for a new primary and secondary school, and a sports hub. It can therefore be determined that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,"The site should be required to provide infrastructure/community facilities to support growth, such as primary/secondary schools and employment land. ",null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S04 Quality of Life\nTo create safe and attractive places which contribute towards quality of life and community cohesion.","S04","· Will it contribute towards reducing crime or fear of crime?\n· Will it provide attractive places which provide opportunities for communities to mix and meet?","No",null,null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, which requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction. The development of this site in isolation is unlikely to contribute towards designing out crime or enhancing community cohesion. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S05 Inequalities\nEnsure all residents have equitable access to employment, education, community services and facilities irrespective of race, religion, sex, age, sexual orientation, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership or pregnancy/maternity.","S05","· Ensure the option / policy does not have an adverse/ discriminatory impact on protected characteristics/ equality groups?\n· Will it narrow the inequality gap between the richest and poorest in the District?\n· Will it reduce inequalities associated with deprivation across the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U16&\":$AX$\"&$U16),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U16&\":$AX$\"&$U16),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U16&\":$AX$\"&$U16),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","This site is within a low IMD deprivation area. However, development of this site alone will not necessarily reduce the gap between the richest and poorest in the District. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S06 Economy\nTo deliver growth in key employment sectors and support the creation of new and retention of existing businesses in urban and rural areas.","S06","· Will it encourage the creation of new businesses and existing businesses to grow?\n· Will it encourage economic diversification?\n· Will it help support and encourage the growth of the local economy (including in rural areas)?\n· Will it support the enhancement of the District’s tourism and cultural offer?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U17&\":$AX$\"&$U17),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U17&\":$AX$\"&$U17),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U17&\":$AX$\"&$U17),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space. Development here could also indirectly support existing businesses within Findern local centre and Derby City. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S07 Employment\nTo create greater employment opportunities and higher value jobs across the whole District","S07","· Will it help to improve skills levels and access to training within the District?\n· Will it reduce unemployment rates overall and reduce disparities which exist across different parts of the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U18&\":$AX$\"&$U18),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U18&\":$AX$\"&$U18),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U18&\":$AX$\"&$U18),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space, and is located around 1.5km from a large employment site (the Toyota manufacturing site). The site will also subsequently be located around 2km from the East Midlands Intermodal Park once built. There will subsequently be a large number of employment opportunities both on- and off-site for residents. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","No",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S08 Infrastructure\nTo deliver improved infrastructure to support growth and economic competitiveness of urban and rural businesses and communities.","S08","· Will it minimise the impact of traffic congestion on the strategic and local road network through the delivery of new or enhanced transport infrastructure?\n· Will it provide opportunities to access key services, including doctor’s surgeries, education facilities, employment and town, local or village centres by means other than car?\n· Will it make the best use of other infrastructure which serves new development?","No",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U19&\":$AX$\"&$U19),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U19&\":$AX$\"&$U19),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U19&\":$AX$\"&$U19),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located near to existing infrastructure with the nearest secondary school being 3km walking distance (with capacity), and the nearest GP surgery, existing employment site, and formal and informal recreation sites being over 800m walking distance. However, Policy INF1 highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision of community facilities. It can therefore be determined that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S09 Sustainable Travel\nTo promote sustainable travel habits including walking, cycling and public transport (bus and rail) usage.  ","S09","· Will it reduce journey lengths and times? \n· Will it maximise opportunities for walking and cycling?\n· Will it maximise opportunities to access public transport provision?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U20&\":$AX$\"&$U20),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U20&\":$AX$\"&$U20),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U20&\":$AX$\"&$U20),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Positive","The site currently lies within an acceptable distance to an existing bus stop, and to existing cycle routes. The site is more than 800m from a train station however. Policy INF1 highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision and improvement of transport infrastructure. For example, the site plan references the provision of new and upgrading pedestrian and cycle routes. This should improve travel within South Derbyshire, as well as into Derby City. It can therefore be determined that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a potential minor positive effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. ",null,"The site should be required to provide improved transport facilities (e.g.: new bus stops), as well as connect to existing pedestrian/cycle routes where possible.",null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S010 Town and Village Centres\nTo ensure that town and village centres are vibrant and viable.","S010","· Will it improve existing shopping facilities within town and village centres? \n· Will it help safeguard existing town and village centres?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U21&\":$AX$\"&$U21),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U21&\":$AX$\"&$U21),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U21&\":$AX$\"&$U21),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located within or adjacent to a town or village centre (it is located on the edge of Derby City, and around 1.5km from the village of Findern). The development of a new local centre within the site would provide local facilities for new residents, enabling some self containment. These facilities would not be designed to provide facilities for the wider area and would not therefore detract from existing town and village centres. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,"Development proposals could be accompanied by an assessment of the impact of the development on the local economy. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S011 Resources\nTo minimise waste and ensure the sustainable use and protection of natural resources including greenfield land, soil and minerals resources.  ","S011","· Will it enhance opportunities for increased levels of recycling in the District?\n· Will it improve or remediate contaminated land or reuse previously developed land which has not been restored?\n· Will it protect Best and Most Versatile (BMV) Agricultural Land?\n· Will it avoid the sterilisation of minerals resources?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U22&\":$AX$\"&$U22),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U22&\":$AX$\"&$U22),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U22&\":$AX$\"&$U22),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Negative","This site is located on grade 3 agricultural land; development will subsequently lead to the irreversible loss of greenfield land, and soils considered as the 'best and most versatile'. The site does not lie within a sand and gravel mineral safeguarding zone or a historic landfill site. The development of this site in isolation will likely have no influence on the levels of recycling across South Derbyshire. However, Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, will requires developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection. Therefore, as the loss of greenfield land/Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated, a potential significant negative effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence will require developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection.","Loss of greenfield land and Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S012 Pollution\nTo minimise water, air, light and noise pollution and ensure that future growth does not lead to the further deterioration of environmental conditions.","S012","· Will it contribute to improvements in water quality in the District?\n· Will it avoid increasing noise levels locally or introducing incompatible uses into an already noisy location?\n· Will it avoid deterioration in air quality within the District?\n· Will it avoid exacerbating light pollution by keeping external lighting to the minimum required for safety and security?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U23&\":$AX$\"&$U23),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U23&\":$AX$\"&$U23),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U23&\":$AX$\"&$U23),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site currently experiences high noise pollution and some light pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase both noise and light pollution. The A38 and A516 are located adjacent to the site so the site is currently exposed to some air pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase air pollution in South Derbyshire, as well as in Derby City as residents may commute into the city for work. The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures, although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes",null,"The developmente should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S013 Contributions to Climate Change \nTo reduce the District’s contribution towards the emission of climate change gases.","S013","· Will it provide opportunities to access local services and facilities by public transport walking or cycling?\n· Will it support the delivery of renewable energy capacity (including small scale or community energy projects)?\n· Will it support the shift toward usage of electric and ultralow emissions vehicles? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U24&\":$AX$\"&$U24),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U24&\":$AX$\"&$U24),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U24&\":$AX$\"&$U24),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is within 600m from an EV charger. However mitigation will be provided by Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport, which will require the development to make provision for EV chargers. Additionally, the sites location (near to Derby City) may assist in the development of heat networks incorporating new homes, providing low carbon heating for future residents. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport will require  developments to make provision for EV chargers.",null,"The site should be built to low-carbon standards with high levels of energy efficiency and individual energy generation technologies (e.g.: heat source pumps, solar PV) being be promoted where possible.",null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S014 Adaptation to Climate Change \nTo manage the effects of climate change including flood risk, reduced water availability and overheating.","S014","· Will it minimise flood risk?\n· Will it include provision of sustainable urban drainage which mimic natural drainage patterns?\n· Will it contribute towards sustainable water use?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U25&\":$AX$\"&$U25),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U25&\":$AX$\"&$U25),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U25&\":$AX$\"&$U25),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Negative","Part of the site lies within Flood Zone 2 and within 1000m of a watercourse, which may place development on the site at risk of flooding. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy SD2 Flood Risk, which will require the site to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. Although this won't eradicate flood risk, it will reduce the likelihood of a flood risk event taking place. Therefore, as the site is still at risk of flood events following policy mitigation, a potential minor negative effect is identified.","No","Policy SD2 Flood Risk will require developments to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. \n",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S015 Townscape and Historic Environment\nTo conserve and enhance the townscape, historic environment, heritage assets (including known and unknown archaeological sites) and their settings. ","S015","· Will it protect and enhance the condition and setting of historic, cultural, architectural and archaeological features in South Derbyshire?\n· Does it improve the quality of the built environment, and respect and protect existing townscape character?\n· Will it improve access to, and understanding of, the District’s historic and cultural assets for enjoyment and educational purposes?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U26&\":$AX$\"&$U26),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U26&\":$AX$\"&$U26),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U26&\":$AX$\"&$U26),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","There are no known heritage assets within the site or wihtin 50m. However, there are two listed buildings within 150m: Grade II Church at Pastures Hospitals and Grade II Winter Garden at Pastures Hospital. Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will refuse the majority of proposals that lead to substantial harm of a heritage asset, although some proposals may still be allowed if it can be demonstrated that the benefit of the development outweighs the harm of damaging the asset. Policy BNE2 also supports proposals that make a positive contribution to heritage assets including listed buildings. It may be possible to mitigate potential harm to the nearby listed buildings and mitigation would be required in the form of policy wording for a site allocation. An uncertain effect is therefore identified.","No","Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will refuse proposals that would lead to substantial harm, unless if can be demonstrated that benefit outweighs the harm. ","Policy wording should ensure that heritage assets are protected from harm and their setting is improved if possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]
["S016 Landscape\nTo conserve and enhance the District’s landscape character.","S016","· Does it respect and protect existing landscape character?\n· Will it protect sensitive landscapes including those within the World Heritage Site or its buffer or Special Landscape Areas?\n· Will it safeguard landscape features such as hedgerows?\n· Will it avoid intrusion into the greenbelt?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U27&\":$AX$\"&$U27),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U27&\":$AX$\"&$U27),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$U27&\":$AX$\"&$U27),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site contributes towards protecting landscape character and sensitive landscapes as it does not lie within the Greenbelt or any areas of multiple environmental sensitivity. However, the development of this site could lead to the 'trapping in' of current green wedges within Derby City, cutting these greenfield land areas off from the surrounding open land. This could alter the current townscape, both within South Derbyshire and Derby City. The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City where possible, in order to minimise impacts of 'trapping', although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation.  Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features.","The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City, in order to maintain a similar landscape pattern. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":7}]

{"sheet":"Site_4","index":9,"n_rows":27,"n_cols":22,"rows_kept":27,"cut":false,"hidden":false,"merged":[[9,0,9,2],[9,3,9,6],[9,7,9,17]]}
["Site Name",null,"Site_4"]
["Site Address",null,"South of Littleover"]
["Town/Locality",null,"Twyford & Stenson and Stenson Fields"]
["Est Housing Yield/Employment Space",null,"7,200 dwellings/ up to 10ha employment space"]
["Site Area (ha)",null,361]
["Site Description",null,"The site suggests the provision of:\n- A new primary school\n- A new train station linked to the South Derby Integrated Transport Link development"]
["Greenfield/Brownfield",null,"Greenfield"]
["Assumptions Made",null,"This allocation will work alongside the policies set out in the South Derbyshire Local Plan Part 1."]
[]
["SA Framework",null,null,"GIS Inputs",null,null,null,"SA Policy Assessment"]
["SA objective","SA","SA sub-objective","GIS Data Available?","R","A","G","Direct/\nIndirect","Magnitude","Duration","Spatial Extent","Permanence/ Reversibility","Significance","Description of potential effects","Potential for cumulative effects? ","Policy Mitigation","Mitigation Recommendations","Enhancement Recommendation","SDDC Comments",null,null,"Link "]
["S01 Biodiversity\nTo safeguard and enhance biodiversity (including BAP habitats and species) and geodiversity through biodiversity net gain and improve connectivity between, and access to, green spaces and functional habitats.","S01","· Will it conserve and enhance natural or semi natural habitats including internationally, nationally and locally designated wildlife sites, or create new wildlife habitats, and contribute to the creation of a network of habitats and green infrastructure in the District?\n· Will it protect BAP or protected species and contribute to the delivery of new, or safeguard existing BAP priority species and habitats?\n· Will it protect sites of geological importance?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V12&\":$AX$\"&$V12),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B12)","v":3},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permenant/Reversible","Minor Positive","There are no designations for nature conservation within the site. The site is located within 50m of a LIG however, and contains a number of TPOs. Development may subsequently negatively impact on biodiversity. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy BNE3 Biodiversity, which requires development to avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG. Therefore, an overall minor positive effect is predicted.","Yes","Policy BNE3 Biodiversity requires developments to  avoid any adverse impact on sites of nature conservation value, as well as deliver a minimum of 10% BNG, in line with national policy requirements.",null,"The site should implement blue/green infrastructure where possible, particularly where the site can be connected to the Derby City Green Wedge. The site should also maintain as much existing vegetation as possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S02 Housing\nTo ensure everyone has access to sustainable housing, which is affordable, and meets the needs of all residents including the elderly and other vulnerable groups and will support the vitality of existing communities and settlements. ","S02","· Will it reduce the number of households waiting for accommodation or accepted as homeless?\n· Will it increase the number and mix of housing? \n· Will it improve the suitability of new homes for older and disabled people?\n· Will it provide affordable housing for those unable to access market housing?\n· Will it meet the needs of the travelling community and show people?\n· Will it secure infrastructure or community facilities?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V13&\":$AX$\"&$V13),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B13)","v":1},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site proposes to provide up to 7,200 dwellings. It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy H20 Affordable Housing, which requires developments within 10 or more dwellings to provide 40% of the gross number of dwellings in the form of  'affordable housing', and alongside Policy H19 Housing Balance and Custom/Self-build, which requires developments to provide a mixed size and tenure of dwellings. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S03 Accessibility and Health\nTo improve local accessibility to healthcare, education, employment, retail facilities and recreational resources (including open spaces and sports facilities) and enhance wellbeing, promoting healthy and sustainable lifestyles.","S03","· Will it promote healthy lifestyles?\n· Will it deliver new, or contribute to the expansion or improvement of existing open spaces, green infrastructure, schools or healthcare facilities within reasonable walking distance?\n· Will it deliver growth within reasonable walking distance to a planned or existing major employment area (5ha +) or town centre?\n· Will it improve opportunities for active travel including walking and cycling?\n· Will it deliver services or facilities on-site or elsewhere within the District? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V14&\":$AX$\"&$V14),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B14)","v":2},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site has good access to a primary school which currently has capacity. However, the site has poor access to: a secondary school which is 3km walking distance (with capacity); over 1km to a GP surgery; and over 800m to formal and informal recreation. Mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,"The site should provide infrastructure/community facilities to support growth, such as primary/secondary schools and employment land. ",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S04 Quality of Life\nTo create safe and attractive places which contribute towards quality of life and community cohesion.","S04","· Will it contribute towards reducing crime or fear of crime?\n· Will it provide attractive places which provide opportunities for communities to mix and meet?","No",null,null,null,"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","It is assumed that this allocation works alongside Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, which requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction. The development of this site in isolation is unlikely to contribute towards designing out crime or enhancing community cohesion. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence requires developments to be designed to minimise opportunities for crime and anti-social behaviour, and encourage diversity and social interaction.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S05 Inequalities\nEnsure all residents have equitable access to employment, education, community services and facilities irrespective of race, religion, sex, age, sexual orientation, disability, gender reassignment, marriage and civil partnership or pregnancy/maternity.","S05","· Ensure the option / policy does not have an adverse/ discriminatory impact on protected characteristics/ equality groups?\n· Will it narrow the inequality gap between the richest and poorest in the District?\n· Will it reduce inequalities associated with deprivation across the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V16&\":$AX$\"&$V16),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B16)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","This site is within a medium IMD deprivation area. However, development of this site alone will not necessarily reduce the gap between the richest and poorest in the District. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S06 Economy\nTo deliver growth in key employment sectors and support the creation of new and retention of existing businesses in urban and rural areas.","S06","· Will it encourage the creation of new businesses and existing businesses to grow?\n· Will it encourage economic diversification?\n· Will it help support and encourage the growth of the local economy (including in rural areas)?\n· Will it support the enhancement of the District’s tourism and cultural offer?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V17&\":$AX$\"&$V17),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B17)","v":1},"Indirect","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space. Development here could also indirectly support existing businesses within Findern local centre and Derby City. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,"The site should be required to provide retail facilities to support growth.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S07 Employment\nTo create greater employment opportunities and higher value jobs across the whole District","S07","· Will it help to improve skills levels and access to training within the District?\n· Will it reduce unemployment rates overall and reduce disparities which exist across different parts of the District?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V18&\":$AX$\"&$V18),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B18)","v":2},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","District-wide","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Positive","The site will deliver up to 10ha of employment space. Additionally, the site is located around 3km from a large employment site (the Toyota manufacturing site), and will subsequently be located around 3km from the East Midlands Intermodal Park once built. As a result, there will be a large number of employment opportunities off-site for residents. Therefore, a potential significant positive effect is identified.","No",null,null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S08 Infrastructure\nTo deliver improved infrastructure to support growth and economic competitiveness of urban and rural businesses and communities.","S08","· Will it minimise the impact of traffic congestion on the strategic and local road network through the delivery of new or enhanced transport infrastructure?\n· Will it provide opportunities to access key services, including doctor’s surgeries, education facilities, employment and town, local or village centres by means other than car?\n· Will it make the best use of other infrastructure which serves new development?","No",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":3},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V19&\":$AX$\"&$V19),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B19)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not located near to existing infrastructure such as employment space, GP practice, secondary school or formal/informal recreation. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision of community facilities. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S09 Sustainable Travel\nTo promote sustainable travel habits including walking, cycling and public transport (bus and rail) usage.  ","S09","· Will it reduce journey lengths and times? \n· Will it maximise opportunities for walking and cycling?\n· Will it maximise opportunities to access public transport provision?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V20&\":$AX$\"&$V20),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B20)","v":2},"N/A","N/A",null,"N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site currently lies within an acceptable distance to an existing bus stop, and to existing cycle routes, but is more than 800m from an existing train station. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy INF1, which highlights that new development will only be permitted if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place; this includes the provision and improvement of transport infrastructure. For example, a new train station may be developed next to the site as part of the South Derbyshire Integrated Transport Link. This should improve travel within South Derbyshire, as well as into Derby City. It can therefore be assumed that infrastructure to support growth will be delivered alongside development. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF1 Infrastructure and Developer Contributions will only permit development if necessary infrastructure (both on- and off-site) is already in place. ",null,"The site should provide improved transport facilities (e.g.: new bus stops), as well as connect to existing pedestrian/cycle routes where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S010 Town and Village Centres\nTo ensure that town and village centres are vibrant and viable.","S010","· Will it improve existing shopping facilities within town and village centres? \n· Will it help safeguard existing town and village centres?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V21&\":$AX$\"&$V21),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B21)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is located on the edge of Derby City, and less than 800m from the village of Findern. The development of a new local centre within the site would provide local facilities for new residents, enabling some self containment. These facilities would not be designed to provide facilities for the wider area and would not therefore detract from existing town and village centres. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","Yes",null,null,"The site should be required to provide retail facilities to support growth.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S011 Resources\nTo minimise waste and ensure the sustainable use and protection of natural resources including greenfield land, soil and minerals resources.  ","S011","· Will it enhance opportunities for increased levels of recycling in the District?\n· Will it improve or remediate contaminated land or reuse previously developed land which has not been restored?\n· Will it protect Best and Most Versatile (BMV) Agricultural Land?\n· Will it avoid the sterilisation of minerals resources?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":4},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V22&\":$AX$\"&$V22),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B22)","v":0},"Direct","Low","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Significant Negative","This site is located on grade 3 agricultural land; development will subsequently lead to the irreversible loss of greenfield land, and soils considered as the 'best and most versatile'. The site also lies partially within a sand and gravel mineral safeguarding zone and a historic landfill site; development may subsequently lead to the sterilisation of mineral resources. The development of this site in isolation will likely have no influence on the levels of recycling across South Derbyshire. However, Policy BNE1 Design Excellence, will requires developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection. Therefore, as the loss of greenfield land/Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated, a potential significant negative effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE1 Design Excellence will require developments to provide adequate space for waste storage and collection.","Loss of greenfield land and Grade 3 agricultural land cannot be mitigated.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S012 Pollution\nTo minimise water, air, light and noise pollution and ensure that future growth does not lead to the further deterioration of environmental conditions.","S012","· Will it contribute to improvements in water quality in the District?\n· Will it avoid increasing noise levels locally or introducing incompatible uses into an already noisy location?\n· Will it avoid deterioration in air quality within the District?\n· Will it avoid exacerbating light pollution by keeping external lighting to the minimum required for safety and security?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V23&\":$AX$\"&$V23),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B23)","v":3},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site currently experiences low noise pollution and some light pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase both noise and light pollution. The A38 and A50 are located adjacent to the site so the site is currently exposed to some air pollution. It is likely that development at this scale will increase air pollution in South Derbyshire, as well as in Derby City as residents may commute into the city for work. The site does not lie within the River Mease nutrient neutrality zone or any groundwater protection zones. The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures, although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes",null,"The site should be required to implement noise and light mitigation measures.",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S013 Contributions to Climate Change \nTo reduce the District’s contribution towards the emission of climate change gases.","S013","· Will it provide opportunities to access local services and facilities by public transport walking or cycling?\n· Will it support the delivery of renewable energy capacity (including small scale or community energy projects)?\n· Will it support the shift toward usage of electric and ultralow emissions vehicles? ","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V24&\":$AX$\"&$V24),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B24)","v":0},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is more than 600m from an EV charger. However mitigation will be provided by Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport, which will require the development to make provision for EV chargers. Additionally, the sites location (near to Derby City) may assist in the development of heat networks incorporating new homes, providing low carbon heating for future residents. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified.","No","Policy INF2 Sustainable Transport will require  developments to make provision for EV chargers.",null,"The site should be built to low-carbon standards with high levels of energy efficiency and individual energy generation technologies (e.g.: heat source pumps, solar PV) being be promoted where possible.",null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S014 Adaptation to Climate Change \nTo manage the effects of climate change including flood risk, reduced water availability and overheating.","S014","· Will it minimise flood risk?\n· Will it include provision of sustainable urban drainage which mimic natural drainage patterns?\n· Will it contribute towards sustainable water use?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":2},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V25&\":$AX$\"&$V25),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B25)","v":0},"Direct","Medium","Medium/Long","Localised","Permanent/Irreversible","Minor Negative","The site lies within Flood Zone 3 and within 10m of a watercourse, which may place development on the site at risk of flooding. However, mitigation will be provided by Policy SD2 Flood Risk which will require the site to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. Although this won't eradicate flood risk, it will reduce the likelihood of a flood risk event taking place. Therefore, as the site is still at risk of flood events following policy mitigation, a potential minor negative effect is identified.","No","Policy SD2 Flood Risk will require developments to incorporate flood risk mitigation, such as SuDs. ",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S015 Townscape and Historic Environment\nTo conserve and enhance the townscape, historic environment, heritage assets (including known and unknown archaeological sites) and their settings. ","S015","· Will it protect and enhance the condition and setting of historic, cultural, architectural and archaeological features in South Derbyshire?\n· Does it improve the quality of the built environment, and respect and protect existing townscape character?\n· Will it improve access to, and understanding of, the District’s historic and cultural assets for enjoyment and educational purposes?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V26&\":$AX$\"&$V26),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B26)","v":4},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Neutral","The site is not within close proximity to any designated heritage assets. Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will also refuse the majority of proposals that lead to substantial harm of a heritage asset, unless it can be demonstrated that the benefit of the development outweighs the harm of damaging the asset. Therefore, a neutral effect is identified. ","No","Policy BNE2 Heritage Assets will refuse proposals that would lead to substantial harm, unless if can be demonstrated that benefit outweights the harm.",null,null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]
["S016 Landscape\nTo conserve and enhance the District’s landscape character.","S016","· Does it respect and protect existing landscape character?\n· Will it protect sensitive landscapes including those within the World Heritage Site or its buffer or Special Landscape Areas?\n· Will it safeguard landscape features such as hedgerows?\n· Will it avoid intrusion into the greenbelt?","Yes",{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),E$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":0},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),F$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":1},{"$f":"COUNTIFS(INDIRECT(\"RAG!$C$\"&$V27&\":$AX$\"&$V27),G$11,RAG!$C$2:$AX$2,$B27)","v":1},"N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","N/A","Uncertain","The site does not lie within the Greenbelt. However, it does lie within a secondary area of multiple environmental sensitivity and a landscape character area. Additionally, the development of this site could lead to the 'trapping in' of current green wedges within Derby City, cutting these greenfield land areas off from the surrounding open land. This could alter the current townscape, both within South Derbyshire and Derby City. Mitigation will be provided by Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness, which will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features. The site should also link to existing green wedges within Derby City where possible, in order to minimise impacts of 'trapping', although it is not clear whether all potential effects can be minimised through mitigation. Therefore, an uncertain effect is identified.","Yes","Policy BNE4 Landscape Character and Local Distinctiveness will require developments to conserve local distinctiveness, retain landscape features (e.g.: hedgerows) and offset any damage to landscape features.","The site should link to existing green wedges within Derby City, in order to maintain a similar landscape pattern. ",null,null,null,null,{"$f":"MATCH($C$1,RAG!$B$1:$B$10, 0)","v":8}]

{"sheet":"Sheet1","index":10,"n_rows":86,"n_cols":12,"rows_kept":86,"cut":false,"hidden":true,"merged":[]}
["Area of search code","Settlement heirarchy","Area of search","LA","Site code","Site name","Potential capacity","Notes","Achieveable? ","Available","Suitable","Allocaed? "]
["C1","DUA","SDDC DUA - west","AVBC","AVBC-2021-0009","Land off Brun Lane, Mackworth",2000,"Assessed at 2000, but promoted capacity of 2250","Y","Y","Y","Y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"AVBC","AVBC-2014-0014","Land off Radbourne Lane, Mackworth",600,null,"Y","Y","Y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",252,"Land off Staker Lane, Derby",3657,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","Y","n - land north of Etwall road is not available","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",155,"Land at Bannell's Lane and Etwall Road, Mickleover",247,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",123,"Land north of Hospital Lane, Mickleover",234,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",136,"Land south of Mickleover",3066,"promoted as 1500-2000","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",221,"Land south of Mickleover",2230,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","Rural",null,"SDDC",246,"Land on the north side at Etwall Lane Burnaston",104,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","Rural",null,"SDDC",245,"Land at Etwall Lane Burnaston",34,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","Rural",null,"SDDC",247,"Land at Elmfield Burnaston",7,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","Rural",null,"SDDC",218,"Partrap House Etwall",64,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",158,"Land nto the north of New Buildings Farm Burnaston",846,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",210,"Land on the west side of Burton Road Burnaston",238,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",84,"Lnad west of Skater Lane Mickleover (Micklemeadow Farm)",399,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",159,"New Rnage Farm Burnaston",352,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["C1","DUA",null,"SDDC",190,"Land adjacent to Fourways, Little Derby Hill Burnaston",1,"Site would need further investigation for residential development; bungalow dwelling refused in 2014, proposed for office space uses. ","y","y","y"]
["C2","Rural","A50 rural ","SDDC",214,"Land north of DC2 Woodyard Lane",0,"Not a residential site","y","y"]
["C2","Rural",null,"SDDC",24,"Land south of Uttoxeter Road Foston",137,"Also a general warehouse and industrial site - need to clarify position","y","y","y"]
["C2","Rural",null,"SDDC",253,"Land to the east of Dove Valley Park",0,"Not resi - for industrial"]
["C2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",201,"Hatton Hall Hatton",121,"Promoted at 150 dwellings","y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village","Hilton Outskirts","SDDC",227,"Sutton Lane Hilton",138,null,"y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",32,"Land at Derby Road Hilton",94,"Assessed as resi, or mixed use or emp site. SHELAA assessed number used here, but promoted at 130","y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",150,"Talbot Farm 75 Derby Road Hilton",0,"Not resi - for industrial"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",65,"Land north of Derby Road Hilton",41,null,"y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",64,"Land at Lucas Lane Hilton",42,"promoted as 57","y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",163,"Land north of Egginton Road and east of Lucas Lane Holton",822,null,"y","y","y"]
["D1","Key service village",null,"SDDC",202,"Egginton Road Hilton",232,"Site not entirely wihtin area of search- around 30% in it","y","y","y"]
["D2","Local Service village","Willington outskirts","SDDC",162,"Land north east of the A38 A50 Toyota junction Findern",590,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",96,"Axis 50 Willington",0,"Not a residential site"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",35,"Land east of Etwall Road Willington",329,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",114,"Land at mercia Marine 1 Findern Lane Willington",48,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",113,"Land to north of the Castle Way Willington",52,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",106,"Land off Etwall Road Willington",305,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",37,"Land South of the Castle Way Willington Part 1",29,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",38,"Land South of the Castle Wat Willington Part 2",29,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",233,"Castleway Willington",31,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",115,"land at Mercia Marine Findern Lane Willington",0,"Proposed for assisted living and age restricted housing","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",117,"Land at Mercia marine Findern Lane Willington",0,"No resitdential development proposed - office, retail, catering","y","y"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",116,"Land at Mercia Marina Findern Lane Willington",0,"no residential - leisure and tourism use"]
["D2","Key service village",null,"SDDC",138,"Willington Power Station",1532,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D3","DUA","SDDC DUA - south","SDDC",139,"Land to east and west of Stenson Road",407,"promoted proposed yield 480-560 dwellings","y","y","y"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",90,"Infinity Garden Village land between Sinfin and Chellaston",4000,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",225,"Arleston Farm Barrow",96,"Noted that yield could change due to BNG requirements","y","y","y"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",131,"Former Derby Canal Swarkestone",0,"No residential - Canal and multiuser path"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",57,"land north west of Swarkestone Road Chellaston",0,"No residential - office, research and developments and light industrial"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",55,"East of Swarkestone Road Chellaston",0,"No residential - office, research and developments and light industrial"]
["D3","DUA",null,"SDDC",61,"Land to the East side of Swardestone Road, Spring Farm Chellaston",0,"No residential - office, research and developments and light industrial"]
["D3","Rural area/DUA",null,"SDDC",46,"Thulstone Fields",2138,"Promoted proposeld yield of 1750","y","y"]
["D3","Key service village",null,"SDDC",80,"Land to the north of Chellastone Lane Aston on Trent",106,"promoted as 100","y","y","y"]
["D3","Key service village",null,"SDDC",107,"Land off Weston Road Aston on Trent",195,"promoted as 100-200","y","y","y"]
["D3",null,null,"SDDC"]
["E1","Rural","Lilypool and surrounding areas","SDDC",105,"Land east of Kings Newton",749,"promoted as 900","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",207,"Land north of Blackwell Lane Melbourne",580,"promoted as 500","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",98,"Land south of Station Road Melbourne",120,"promoted as 160","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",13,"Land off Main Street Kings Newton",22,"promoted as 9","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",238,"Main Street Kings Netwon",95,null,"y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",17,"Land north and south of Jawbone Lane Melbourne",103,null,"y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",19,"Land north of Jawbone Lane Melbourne",23,"promoted as 8 site","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",78,"Land at Main Street Melbourne",91,"91 ntoed as a max figure; promoted as 95 dwellings","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",79,"Land at Main Street Melbourne",44,"44 noted as a max figure; promoted as 42","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",168,"Kings Newton Lane Part 2 Kings Newton",34,"site only partially within area of search","y","y","y"]
["E1","Rural",null,"SDDC",87,"Land north of Blackwell Lane Melbourne",72,null,"y","y","y"]
["E1",null,null,"SDDC"]
["E2","Urban area/rural","Burton upon Trent extension","SDDC",52,"Land at Newton Road Newton Solney",144,"promoted as 85","y","y","y"]
["E2","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",147,"Land off Newton Road Newton Solney",57,"promoted as 47","y","y","y"]
["E2","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",86,"Land at Sales Lane Burton",266,"promoted as 150","y","y","y"]
["E2","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",14,"Land off Ashby Road East Bretby",65,"promoted as 70","y","y","n - located in GB"]
["E2","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",93,"Land south of Ashby Road East Burton upon Trent",1647,"promoted as 1800","y","y","n - located in GB"]
["E3","Urban area/rural","Swadlincote extension - west","SDDC",184,"Site D north of William Nadin Way Woodview Road Swadlincote",236,"promoted as 150","y","y","y"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",250,"Land at Cadley Park",0,"Not resi - offices and leisure centre"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",241,"Land at Woodland Road Stanton",28,"promoted as 30-50","y","y","n - a number of crieteria requiring mitigation"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",243,"Land at 42 Woodland Road Stanton",38,null,"y","y","n - located in GB"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",195,"Land at Cadley Lane Castle Gresley",569,"mixed use site - light industrial and/or general industrial to accompany","y","y","y"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",6,"Land West of Burton Road Castle Gresley",566,"promoted as 500-550","y","y","y"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",132,"Land south of Cadley Hill Industrial Estate Swadlincote",107,"promoted as 80-100","y","y","y"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",213,"Swadlincote Lane Castle Gresley",170,"promoted as 200","y","y","y"]
["E3","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",236,"Sandcliffe Road Swadlincote (phase 1)",null,"inlcuded in 45 footprint? 180 dwellings","y","y","y"]
["E4","Urban area/rural","Swadlincote extension - east","SDDC",45,"Sandcliffe Road Swadlincote",834,"promoted as 500; includes site 236? ","y","y","y"]
["E4","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",39,"Between Hartshorne and Woodville (Goseley Estate)",1017,"broken up into several sites? ","y","y","y"]
["E4","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",177,"Land at Bretby View",35,null,"y","y","y"]
["E4","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC",34,"Land at Ashby Road Woodville",50,"promoted as 45 dwellings","y","y","? - site within River Mease SAC, further investigation required"]
["E4","Urban area/rural",null,"SDDC"]
["E5","Rural village","Simsby outskirts","SDDC",0]
["F1","Rural village","Walton-on-Trent extension","SDDC",211,"Former Draklelow Power Station",0,"renewable energy centre proposal"]
["F1","Rural village",null,"SDDC",72,"Land east of Walton on Trent",2239,"promoted as 2230","y","y","y"]